Friday, January 29, 2016

MADINA POLYCLINIC KILLED MY WIFE, BABY - AGGRIEVED WIDOWER DEMANDS JUSTICE

The deceased, Cynthia, with the husband, Bernard, during their traditional marriage ceremony held 6 months before her death
When Cynthia Nuworsu, an expectant mother, went to the Madina Polyclinic to give birth, it was the hope of her husband and the children that the family would welcome its seventh member, but that was not to be as both mother and child died.

The sudden death of the expectant mother together with her unborn baby at the Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic has set the widower, Bernard Otu (a driver and a native of Odumase-Krobo) and the medical officers of the clinic on a collision course.

The aggrieved husband is threatening to travel the full length to seek justice for what he described as professional negligence on the part of the officers. 

The deceased, Cynthia Nuworsu
He said the circumstance surrounding the death of his 38-year-old wife- a trader and a mother of four- smacks of unprofessionalism that should not pass without thorough investigation, if the precious lives of pregnant women who also intend to give birth in the facility were to be saved.

“The events that led to the death of my otherwise hale and hearty wife smacks of carelessness that must be of great concern to the public and women in particular”, he told these reporters.

Post mortem
A post mortem report from the Police Hospital, dated June 24, 2015, stamped and signed by one Dr. L. Edusei indicated that Cynthia died of “breeched presentation” and a “ruptured uterus during labour”.

According to medical experts, while ruptured uterus is a tear or explosion of the uterus, breeched presentation is a childbirth in which the baby exits the pelvis with the buttocks, feet or any other part of the body as opposed to the normal head-first presentation.
These followed an induced labour and nearly 24 hours of labour characterized by profuse bleeding.

Turned away
Narrating the events that led to his wife’s death, Mr. Out indicated that his partner, who had had her antenatal care at the Polyclinic, was invited on Wednesday June 17, 2015 by officials of the clinic to be delivered of her baby, having been put on a waiting list for delivery due to the lack of beds in the maternity ward of the facility.

On her arrival at the clinic around 5pm on that day, Cynthia (who until then was going about her normal activities), underwent an inducement and could be heard screaming from the ward around 8pm when he (the husband) arrived at the clinic.

Mr. Otu said he requested to see the wife, thinking his presence could soothe the pain or at least make him sure of her condition but he was prevented from entering the ward.

He said, he made three subsequent attempts but they also yielded no result. Angered and frustrated, he returned home, which was just across the walls of the hospital, until around 7am on Thursday June 18, 2015 when he showed up again and requested that his wife should be transferred from the clinic to a hospital due to the prolong labour, but his request was rejected.

He made a return to the facility again around 10am with same request but his wishes were not granted; instead, he was given the assurance by one Hajia, a nurse, that the wife was going to deliver.

Indecisiveness
According to Mr. Otu, he returned home only to receive a call around mid-day that complications had set in and the wife was going to be transferred to the Alpha hospital, also in Madina. He was later told the pain had aggravated and Cynthia was going to be sent to the Ridge hospital instead.

While on his way to the Ridge Hospital amidst anxiety, another call came through informing him that the wife had delivered at the Polyclinic. He returned around 1:30pm anxious to see the wife and the newborn but he was not given access because the nurses claimed the two were being given preliminary postnatal attention.

“I waited with bated breath until around 4:30 when I was invited into a meeting during which the Ag. Medical Officer, one Dr. Selorm Botchwey, surrounded by about six other nurses, broke the sad news of my wife’s death to me”.

According to him, his checks indicated that no effort was made at all to transfer the wife to the Alpha and Ridge hospital as he was earlier made to believe.

The corpse which was still heavy with the foetus (after nearly 24 hours of labour) was handed over to him and the family around 6pm with an accompanying note for a post mortem at the 37 Military Hospital.

They were however turned away on arrival at 37, compelling them to deposit the remains at the Police Hospital where an autopsy was later conducted on Wednesday June 24, 2015.
When contacted, the Acting Medical Officer of the Polyclinic refused to give details except to say “the Regional Health Director is better positioned to comment on the issue”.

Efforts by these reporters to talk to the Regional Health Director have since yielded no result”.

A visit to the office on January 14 and three phone calls subsequently to the secretary of the Regional Director were only met with “she is not around. She has not given me any date to call you”.

Medical negligence in Ghana
Allegations of professional negligence in Ghanaian hospitals are not new.

April 2010
A couple who lost their child through what they term “medical malpractice and professional negligence” demanded GHC 2 million compensation from the Lister Hospital and Fertility Center where the baby died.

Mr. Thomas Vaah and Elizabeth Vaah, who work with the United Nations and World Bank, respectively, plan to use the money as seed money for a foundation they have formed in memory of their late son to provide assistance for parents who undergo a similar ordeal.

The traumatised parents accused the hospital of “gross unprofessional conduct” which led to the death of Nyilale Vaah Junior, who was delivered on Tuesday March 9, 2012; almost 17 hours after Mrs. Vaah had been admitted and had received virtually no attention from healthcare professionals at the hospital.

The hospital’s management, however, denied the allegation.

May 2010
The husband of a 28-year-old woman, Dzifa Agboforti, alleged that unprofessional conduct of nurses of the Ketu South District Hospital at Aflao in the Volta Region resulted in the death of his wife and newborn baby.

Mr. Simon Ackumey said his wife reported to the health facility at about 8 a.m on April 8, 2010 to deliver but the nurses cared little about her presence.

Mr. Ackumey said the following day, the nurses asked his wife to move to another bed despite her plea that she was about to deliver.

He said when the wife got up and walked toward the bed, the baby dropped on the floor, compelling the nurses to rush to pick him and resuscitate him but he died two hours later.

November 2010
A young couple whose twin babies died during delivery at the Tema General Hospital on November 3, 2010 accused the Hospital of “murder” through negligence.

According to them, the two girls could have survived if nurses and doctors on duty had been more responsible and professional in attending to them.

March 2014
The family of 24-year-old pregnant lady at Laterbiokorhsie, a suburb of Accra accused authorities of the Korle-Bu Polyclinic of negligence, causing her death.

Abigail Boateng was almost three months pregnant when she died at the polyclinic on March 2, 2014.

NB: Story by Henking A. Adjase-Kodjo and Seth J. Bokpe

Henking is a journalist (an activist writer) and a blogger and can be reached via klonobi2007@gmail.com. You can follow him on twitter with the handle @henkingklonobi. Don't hesitate to leave the writer a comment on the story read.
The story as captured in the front page of The Mirror newspaper, Fri Jan 29- Feb 4, 2016

Front page of  The Mirror newspaper, Fri Jan 29- Feb 4, 2016

Page 3 of the newspaper

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

FROM INSIDE MY GRAVE, I WRITE TO YOU


Nurses from the Narh Bita hospital (including a female nurse) refilling my grave
From an unmarked grave in a certain cemetery in Ghana, I write to inform you of my safe arrival in the ancestral village. I had a modest send off last Friday (January 22, 2016) at the forecourt of the mortuary where my cadaver was deposited from the day my mortality was proven at the Narh Bita hospital. 

There I was in my narrow bed
I am not sure you will be surprised to hear that I didn’t even have the privilege to be sent home and displayed (mourned) as is the honour usually accorded mortals. All the same, I had what I considered a solemn send-off, and later, a rousing welcome at the gate of the ancestral village.

Before I got drained of life on Sunday January 10, 2016, I had a good feel of the Ghanaian hospitality (the kind of embrace even my own people could not give me) and that, to a very large extent, lessened the sad feeling of worthlessness in the face of the rejection I suffered from my employer and the Liberian embassy.

My nephew, Johny Johnson
I noted a few things that were comforting. My nephew, Johnny Johnson kept faith with me. He offered to leave his comfort zone in Liberia and came to turn me in my sick bed. The doctors and young nurses at the Narh Bita Hospital joined and tried their best to tie my poor soul and body together and so did the lay preachers from the Trinity congregation of the Presbyterian Church of Ghana, Tema Community 4, also visit me regularly to feed my hungry soul with the living word. The presence of these people in my last days and during my burial helped to largely restore my dignity as a human being.

I left this world with missed feeling and that was because my life was cut short- I feel my exit was rushed and yet now I am happy to have found a peaceful rest from my pains and worries. Soon after my accident in that Liberian Port which got me bed-ridden, my wishes to raise my children into responsible adults started fading and now those wishes have completely evaporated but I know God will provide for my children and family.

As I write you this letter, I have taken my supine position in the confines of my narrow bed in the bellies of the earth, soon to be attended to by the termites. But before I am shredded into pieces, I wish to thank Ghanaians for your warm embrace, particularly Dr. Edward Atter Narh, CEO of the Narh Bita Hospital and all who were constantly by my sick bed. I also feel indebted to the management of Kenya Airways for accepting to flying back my nephew and which they did last Saturday; he has since arrived.

As for the Liberian Ambassador and his staff, I was hungry, they gave me nothing to eat; I was thirsty, they gave me nothing to drink; I became a stranger, and they did not invite me in, I was naked and they didn't cloth me. I was sick and they didn't visit me. For now I am resting and doing what they will each do one day. I leave you with William G. Tomer’s song:

God be with you till we meet again;
By his counsels guide, uphold you;
With his sheep securely fold you.
God be with you till we meet again.

(Chorus)
Till we meet, till we meet,
Till we meet at Jesus' feet,
Till we meet, till we meet,
God be with you till we meet again..


Signed
Moses Negbe

(The abandoned Liberian)


Pain and grief boldly written on my nephew's (middle) face

Rev Nii Naa Doku committing me to the Lord




And the nurses took me to my last resting place, while comforting my nephew

Monday, January 11, 2016

CORPORATE NEGLIGENCE: DEJECTED LIBERIAN PATIENT DIES

The Narh Bita Hospital, Tema
The Liberia national who was flown to Ghana for medical attention but ended up being abandoned shortly on arrival by the employer has passed on. He died in the early hours of Sunday January 10, 2015 at the Narh Bita Hospital where he has been on admission since October last year.

The remains have since been deposited at the Tema General Hospital but it is unclear whether the body will be interred here in Ghana or will be repatriated and who takes responsibility from this point.

Moses Negbe while on admission at the Narh Bita Hospital
Fifty four year old Moses Negbe was flown to Ghana for specialist attention by his employer, the Global Marine Investment Limited (GMI) after a workplace accident on August 31, 2015 at a port in Liberia which left him with multiple spine injury.

Due to the complex nature of the injury which could not readily be attended to in Liberia, GMI arranged for his treatment here in Ghana and brought him to the Narh Bita Hospital but abandoned him a few days later.

Despite the numerous contacts made with the GMI officials and the authorities of the Liberian Embassy (Ghana) by the hospital administration, none of the two institutions showed up since October last year.

Until his demise, Mr. Negbe was confined to his bed and could hardly move any part of his body even after the surgery which was successfully conducted on Thursday October 29, 2015.  His post-surgical care and daily upkeep became a burden not only on the facility but the nurses on the ward who contributed to put food on the table for both the patient and his nephew, Johnny Johnson, who accompanied him to Ghana for the treatment.

Presently, his nephew has been left stranded at the hospital with no money to feed or return to his home country following the expiration of his air ticket just the day before his uncle’s death.

Background
Moses Negbe was working in a Liberian port on August 31, 2015 when a log fell from a crane and crushed his colleague to death, leaving him (Negbe) in a critical condition.
He was first rushed to the JFK Medical Centre in Monrovia where he spent forty days but had to be flown out of the country for a specialist attention which was not readily available in the country.

His employer then arranged for his transfer from the hospital in Liberia and made an initial payment for the surgery with a promise to provide for his upkeep while on admission here in Ghana as well as his return back to Liberia after treatment. 

Two weeks after their arrival, the company turned it back on Negbe and his nephew who accompanied him on the treatment. All efforts to reach them including calls to the company’s lead contact who doubles as a Field Agent, one Joe Sayahway, yielded no result.

Liberian Embassy’s indifference
The Liberian Embassy which should have been responsible for Negbe’s welfare (given his predicament and particularly his status as a Liberian national), also showed no interest in the issue, describing it as a private affair despite the numerous phone calls and visits to the consulate by Mr. Negbe’s nephew and official of the hospital.

Response from Narh Bita hospital
Deputy Medical Director of the Narh Bita hospital, Dr. Catherine Larko Narh-Menkah said “We have arranged, in the interim, for him to be deposited in the morgue while we consider the next line of action. As a socially responsible corporate entity, we did our best even under the very difficult condition given his peculiar situation; it is rather sad he went through these terrible experience and died as a result”.