Showing posts with label Kekle Polyclinic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kekle Polyclinic. Show all posts

Friday, February 19, 2016

NURSING AND MIDWIFERY COUNCIL WILL ACT APPROPRIATELY

The Nursing and Midwifery Council says it will take appropriate action in the case in which a 38 year old expectant mother died together with the unborn baby at the Madina Polyclinic, once the court makes it decision known.

The Council indicated that thought it had officially heard from the complainant, it was unable to investigate the issue which is presently before a court of competent jurisdiction.

“Once the case is before court, it incapacitates us as a regulatory body, for which reason we can only act after the court’s decision is out”, the Council indicated in its official response.

The Council said this after meeting the widower at the Council’s premises on Wednesday.


The sad-looking widower, Mr. Otu
Mr. Otu who also confirmed meeting the Council said he was happy the Council had given him audience in response to his petition. “I feel a bit consoled by their embrace and response. We await the outcome of the court case”, he added.

Background
Cynthia Nuworsu, a trader and a mother of four died together with her unborn baby on January 18, 2015 at the Madina Kekle Polyclinic where she had reported the day before to deliver her fifth child.

According to an autopsy report from the Police hospital, she died of “raptured uterus” (a tear of the uterus) and “breech presentation”, explained as childbirth in which the baby exits the pelvis with the buttocks, feet or any other part of the body as opposed to the normal head-first presentation. 

The husband who is presently in a legal tussle with the medical facility described the circumstance surrounding Cynthia’s demise as “medical malpractice” and a “preventable death” which breached the duty of care between the facility and the deceased. He has since file a law suit against the facility and three others.

5 million suit
In what promises to be a landmark legal battle, sure to leave a precedent irrespective of the outcome, lawyer for the widower, Francis Xavier Sosu Esq. last week filed a GHC 5 million suit at the Human Rights Division of the High Court against the Madina Polyclinic.

Joined to the suit are the Minister of Health, Attorney General and the Director General of the Ghana Health Service.

Among others, Council for the plaintiff is praying the court to declare that the duty of care owed the deceased was breached, leading to the painful death of mother and child.

Additionally, he is praying the court to order a compensation to the widower to the tune of GHC 5 million.

Though counsel for the plaintiff confirmed service of the writ on the defendants, it was unclear if the latter had filed their response, at the time of going to press.

Henking A. Adjase-Kodjo & Seth J. Bokpe

Henking is a journalist (an activist writer) and a blogger and can be reached via klonobi2007@gmail.com. You can follow him on twitter with the handle @henkingklonobi. Don't hesitate to leave the writer a comment on the story read

                                                          Friday February 19-25, 2016 pg 3
                            

LAWYER SOSU TAKES UP CASE FOR WIDOWER

Human Rights lawyer, Francis Xavier Sosu
A Human Rights Lawyer, Francis Xavier Sosu has taken up the case of Mr. Bernard Otu, the man who lost his expectant wife and unborn baby at the Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic, pledging to seek justice for the widower.

Mr. Sosu who picked up the case on pro bono basis, said he will file a suit at the Human Rights Division of the High Court before the end of the week to demand justice for the father of four.

He is therefore leading a team of lawyers from his firm, F-X Law and Associate to file a suit at the court.

Mr Sosu, known for championing  the cause of the underprivileged in the country’s law courts, said he was driven mainly by public interest and his background as a human rights lawyer to wade into the issue to give a voice to the distressed young man.

“We are heading to court and will pursue this case to the latter. The Polyclinic had a duty of care to the deceased and his husband and that is what we are out there to prove, at least to help us get things right in our health delivery system”, Mr. Sosu told the Mirror.

While he would not disclose the content of the suit until it was filed, he said he expected justice to be done at the end of the day.

Background
It would be recalled that, 38-year-old Cynthia Nuworsu, a trader and a mother of four, underwent an induction of labour at the Madina Kekle Polyclinic on Wednesday June 17 2015 and died in the process the following day after prolonged labour.

The husband described this as “medical malpractice” and a “preventable death” in breach of the duty of care owed him and the deceased.

This has since pushed him into a confrontation with the medical officers, and he is court bound.  .  

The remains of both baby and mother were interred at Dzodze in the Volta Region.

Widower’s reaction
In an interview, Mr. Otu said he was happy about the growing public interest in the issue and particularly about the intervention of these human rights lawyers.

“This must be the starting point of a more holistic assessment of our systems and the improvement of monitoring and supervision to help address the glaring lapses and to save more lives”, he said.

 Madina Police
The Madia Police have confirmed knowledge of the incident.

They indicated that after the official complaint by the widower on Friday June 19, 2015, they invited the officials of the clinic who could not show up with the excuses that they needed permission from the regional directorate.

Permission was later sought in writing by the Police Service which led to the interrogation of about five of them including one Dr. Selorm Botchwey, said to be the Ag. Medical Director of the facility.


In an interview, DSP Happy Michael Addae, who at the time of the incident was the Madina District Crime Officer (now on transfer) said, “professional negligence, as is being alledged by Mr. Otu, is a tort (civil case) which can only be taken up by the widower” adding “ We can only come on board with the findings from our investigations”.

By Henking A. Adjase-Kodjo & Seth J. Bokpe
                                                     Friday Feb 12-18, 2016 pg 3

Thursday, February 4, 2016

AGGRIEVED WIDOWER PETITIONS HEALTH MINISTER

The couple on the day of their marriage 
In furtherance of his desire to get to the root cause of the death of his expectant wife and child at the Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic, Bernard Otu, the aggrieved widower has petitioned the Minister of Health.

He is asking for thorough investigations into the circumstances surrounding the death of his 38-year-old wife and unborn baby through childbirth at the facility.

Mr Otus is also seeking, among other things, an inquiry into what he described as professional negligence as well as the lack of customer care and fellow feeling which resulted in the irreplaceable loss of two lives.

The three-paged petition, dated January 4, 2016 and addressed to the Health Minister has since been served with copies to other supervisory/regulatory institutions such as the Ghana Health Service (GHS), Nursing and Midwifery Council (NWC), Medical and Dental Council (MDC),  and the Ghana Medical Association (GMA).

Mr. Otu indicated that another of his motivation in pursuing the case was the need for a restructuring of the systems and a proper supervision to save more lives in our quest, as a nation, to reduce the incidence of maternal, perinatal and infant mortality.

Post mortem
A post mortem report from the Police Hospital, dated June 24, 2015, stamped and signed by one Dr. L. Edusei indicated that Cynthia died of “breeched presentation” explained by medical experts as a childbirth in which the baby exits the pelvis with the buttocks, feet or any other part of the body as opposed to the normal head-first presentation.

Per the report, she was also found to have suffered a “uterine rupture”, also explained as tear or explosion of the uterus. These followed an induced labour and nearly 24 hours of labour characterized by profuse bleeding.

Background
Cynthia Nuworsu, the deceased 
Cynthia Nuworsu , a trader and a mother of four, underwent an induction of labour at the Polyclinic on Wednesday June 17 2015 and died in the process the following day, still undelivered.

According to the grieving husband, his demands to have access to the wife and later for a referral to a hospital in the course of the prolonged labour were all ignored until his wife eventually passed away.  

The corpse was later transferred to the Police hospital and subsequently buried at Dzodze in the Volta Region together with the remains of the foetus.

Invitation by national security
Reliable information indicates that the National Security has invited the officers of the Madina Police Station where the case was first reported. 

The Chief of Madina, Serikie Baba Amadu Seidu, who at a point was commissioned by the officers of the Polyclinic to arbitrate the case between them and the widower has also been invited. 

Medical and Dental Council invite
A meeting was held in Accra on Tuesday between officials of the Medical and Dental Council and the widower, at the instance of the former.

According to Mr. Otu, he has been directed by the Registrar of the Council, Dr. Eli Atikpui, to submit an official complaint, attached with what the registrar described as a statutory declaration to enable the council take the necessary actions. He is yet to submit the complaints as requested.

Nana Aba Anamoah supports
Nana Aba Anamoah presenting the cash to the widower
In a related development, Nana Aba Anamoah, a broadcast journalist with GHOne Television (and formerly of TV3) has donated an amount of Thousand Ghana cedis (GHC1000.00) to support the husband and children of the deceased.

Presenting the cash to the widower in the studios of Starr FM last Tuesday shortly after their interview session on the Morning Starr, Nana Aba who was sitting in for Nii Ardey Clegg, the regular host, said “This is my personal contribution to keep you and your children going in this moment of grief. I hope other individuals and institutions will do same to help sooth your sorrow”.

Mr. Otu who received the cash with mixed feeling said “This gesture is unexpected; it means so much to me and I know God will reward you for this gesture”.

Story by Henking A. Adjase-Kodjo and Seth J. Bokpe 

Henking is a journalist (an activist writer) and a blogger and can be reached via klonobi2007@gmail.com. You can follow him on twitter with the handle @henkingklonobi. Don't hesitate to leave the writer a comment on the story read.

The story as captured in page 3 of the Mirror of  Feb 5-11, 2016
NB: A copy of the petition is reproduced below

Post Office Box OK 155
Odumase-Krobo
January 4, 2016

The Minster
Ministry of Health
Accra
Attn: Hon Alex Segbefia

PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE AT THE MADINA (KEKLE) POLYCLINIC AND THE RESULTANT DEATH OF MY EXPECTANT WIFE

Dear Sir,

After thorough reflection and consultations, I have decided to petition your outfit (and the other supervisory institutions) as the first in the series of steps I intend to take on the issue of the death of my expectant wife at the Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic.

It is my conviction that the process leading to her death and the condition in which she passed away smack of professional negligence (a threat to the public) which should not pass without attention and investigation as is in the interest of the public.

Background
My 38 year old wife, Cynthia Nuworsu died, of a raptured uterus and similar complications after an induced and an unreasonably long period of painful labour. On that fateful day, Wednesday June 17, 2015, Cynthia who was going about her normal activities, was called from the hospital- having been put on a waiting list to be delivered of her baby- and admitted in the clinic, where she’s had her antenatal care all this while.

Between her arrival around 5pm on June 17 and death in the afternoon of on June 18 June, 2015, it became obvious that complications had set in (in the delivery process) beyond the capacity of the polyclinic (said to have no operating theatre) and needed to be referred to a better equipped hospital but the medical would not give any credible information on how she was faring. They will neither give me access to her nor grant my requests to have her transferred immediately. All they kept telling me in a rather rude tone was “you are not a Doctor and can’t dictate to us”.

All this while, I could hear my wife’s loud screams, which intensified in equal measure to the aggravated pain and discomfort, arising out of the induced and prolong period of labour.
In short, I was prevented from seeing her and my wish/request to have her referred got ignored until I was grudgingly informed of her passing by the Ag. Medical Officer, Dr. Selorm Botchwey, around 4:30pm, nearly 24 hours after her labour was induced.

The corpse which still had the baby stuck in the tommy was handed over to me around 6pm with a note for a post mortem at the 37 Military Hospitals. Autopsy at the Police Hospital (during which the foetus was removed) later revealed that she died of a ruptured uterus and breech presentation.

The deceased together with the foetus were subsequently buried on Saturday August 8, 2015 at Dzodje in the Volta Region.

Justification for the petition/call for investigation and intended action

Loss of two precious lives: The quantum of loss I have suffered is enormous; at least one life (either the mother or the baby) could and should have been saved; and a little act of professionalism on the part of the medical officers would have achieved that. And isn’t it amazing that even at the time of her death, after nearly 24 hours of labour, the baby was still stuck in the womb?

Indiscretion/professional negligence: Why should an expectant mother be subjected to this long period of labour at a facility that has no operating theatre to take care of likely/resultant complications. And why won’t my insistence on her transfer be enough push for referral to a more advanced medical facility?  This is certainly a clear act of indiscretion and or incompetence which must not go unchecked, if more lived should be saved. Surprising shocking mind-blowing

Lack of customer care and fellow feeling: The arrogance on the part of the medical staff on duty was, to put it mildly, startling and dreadful. It is expected that in this day and age when customer care has virtually become a way of life for any well-managed staff/corporate institution, a husband whose wife is in labour would receive a warm embrace that would be soothing enough to rest his mind during that period of uncertainty. What did I experience- pure pride and a rather haughty manner and feeling of superiority over me which turned hostile what should rather have been a friendly environment. Given their deep-seated attitude (which must be their way of life), when they should be learning from this unfortunate situation, there is the high possibility that another person may be subjected to similar treatment that would lead to the irreversible loss of more precious lives, if swift measures are not taken.

Financial loss: Aside the loss of human lives (my hard-working wife in particular), that has rendered my four children motherless, I have suffered huge financial loss that has virtual grounded what was a thriving transport business on which our very survival was hinged. Life has not been the same.

Need to save more lives: My key motivation in seeking your intervention is the need to act to save more lives. I want to believe that a lot more people have gone through similar experience in silence, not only at the Madina Polyclinic but in our various hospitals (government hospitals in particular) and a lot more will have to be at the receiving end of this ill-treatment unless something drastic was done.

It remains my wish that you personally step into this issue and cause the right thing to be done because it is in largely in the interest of the citizenry so to do.

I count on your swift response

Yours sincerely

Bernard Otu

……………....
Tel: 0244 543 179 / 0270543179


Cc: Director General, Ghana Health Service, Accra
Director, Ghana Medical Association, Accra
Greater Accra Regional Director, Ghana Health Service, Accra
Director, Ghana Health Service, La-Nkwantanan
Deputy Medical Director, Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic
The Konor (Paramount Chief), Manya Krobo
Kloma Gbi
The Registrar, Nursing and Midwifery Council of Ghana, Accra
The President, Ghana Registered Nurses and Midwives Association, Accra
The Registrar, Medical and Dental Council, Accra
NB: Copies updated with the last three recipients



Tuesday, February 2, 2016

NANA ABA ANAMOAH SUPPORTS WIDOWER

Nana Aba Anamoah (right) presenting the cash to Bernard Otoo, the widower in the studios of Starr FM
Nana Aba Anamoah, of GHOne Television (formerly a newscaster and show host at TV3) has donated an amount of Thousand Ghana cedis (GHC1000.00) to support the husband and children of Cynthia Nuworsu, the 38-year-old lady who died during childbirth at the Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic a couple of months ago.  .
Bernard in the studios of Starr FM
Presenting the cash to the widower, Mr. Bernard Otoo, in the studios of Starr FM this morning shortly after their interview session on the Morning Show, Nana Aba who was sitting in for Nii Ardey Clegg, the regular host, said “This is my personal contribution to keep you and your children going in this moment of grief. I'm sure others will come in to help sooth your sorrow”.

Mr. Otoo who received the package with mixed feeling said “This gesture is totally unexpected; it means so much to me and I know God will reward you for this gesture”.

Details of the story on circumstances that led to the death of Cynthia and her baby are available here:  http://thekroboquill.blogspot.com/2016/01/madina-polyclinic-killed-my-wife-baby.html

Henking is a journalist (an activist writer) and a blogger and can be reached via klonobi2007@gmail.com. You can follow him on twitter with the handle @henkingklonobi. Don't hesitate to leave the writer a comment on the story read.

Friday, January 29, 2016

MADINA POLYCLINIC KILLED MY WIFE, BABY - AGGRIEVED WIDOWER DEMANDS JUSTICE

The deceased, Cynthia, with the husband, Bernard, during their traditional marriage ceremony held 6 months before her death
When Cynthia Nuworsu, an expectant mother, went to the Madina Polyclinic to give birth, it was the hope of her husband and the children that the family would welcome its seventh member, but that was not to be as both mother and child died.

The sudden death of the expectant mother together with her unborn baby at the Madina (Kekle) Polyclinic has set the widower, Bernard Otu (a driver and a native of Odumase-Krobo) and the medical officers of the clinic on a collision course.

The aggrieved husband is threatening to travel the full length to seek justice for what he described as professional negligence on the part of the officers. 

The deceased, Cynthia Nuworsu
He said the circumstance surrounding the death of his 38-year-old wife- a trader and a mother of four- smacks of unprofessionalism that should not pass without thorough investigation, if the precious lives of pregnant women who also intend to give birth in the facility were to be saved.

“The events that led to the death of my otherwise hale and hearty wife smacks of carelessness that must be of great concern to the public and women in particular”, he told these reporters.

Post mortem
A post mortem report from the Police Hospital, dated June 24, 2015, stamped and signed by one Dr. L. Edusei indicated that Cynthia died of “breeched presentation” and a “ruptured uterus during labour”.

According to medical experts, while ruptured uterus is a tear or explosion of the uterus, breeched presentation is a childbirth in which the baby exits the pelvis with the buttocks, feet or any other part of the body as opposed to the normal head-first presentation.
These followed an induced labour and nearly 24 hours of labour characterized by profuse bleeding.

Turned away
Narrating the events that led to his wife’s death, Mr. Out indicated that his partner, who had had her antenatal care at the Polyclinic, was invited on Wednesday June 17, 2015 by officials of the clinic to be delivered of her baby, having been put on a waiting list for delivery due to the lack of beds in the maternity ward of the facility.

On her arrival at the clinic around 5pm on that day, Cynthia (who until then was going about her normal activities), underwent an inducement and could be heard screaming from the ward around 8pm when he (the husband) arrived at the clinic.

Mr. Otu said he requested to see the wife, thinking his presence could soothe the pain or at least make him sure of her condition but he was prevented from entering the ward.

He said, he made three subsequent attempts but they also yielded no result. Angered and frustrated, he returned home, which was just across the walls of the hospital, until around 7am on Thursday June 18, 2015 when he showed up again and requested that his wife should be transferred from the clinic to a hospital due to the prolong labour, but his request was rejected.

He made a return to the facility again around 10am with same request but his wishes were not granted; instead, he was given the assurance by one Hajia, a nurse, that the wife was going to deliver.

Indecisiveness
According to Mr. Otu, he returned home only to receive a call around mid-day that complications had set in and the wife was going to be transferred to the Alpha hospital, also in Madina. He was later told the pain had aggravated and Cynthia was going to be sent to the Ridge hospital instead.

While on his way to the Ridge Hospital amidst anxiety, another call came through informing him that the wife had delivered at the Polyclinic. He returned around 1:30pm anxious to see the wife and the newborn but he was not given access because the nurses claimed the two were being given preliminary postnatal attention.

“I waited with bated breath until around 4:30 when I was invited into a meeting during which the Ag. Medical Officer, one Dr. Selorm Botchwey, surrounded by about six other nurses, broke the sad news of my wife’s death to me”.

According to him, his checks indicated that no effort was made at all to transfer the wife to the Alpha and Ridge hospital as he was earlier made to believe.

The corpse which was still heavy with the foetus (after nearly 24 hours of labour) was handed over to him and the family around 6pm with an accompanying note for a post mortem at the 37 Military Hospital.

They were however turned away on arrival at 37, compelling them to deposit the remains at the Police Hospital where an autopsy was later conducted on Wednesday June 24, 2015.
When contacted, the Acting Medical Officer of the Polyclinic refused to give details except to say “the Regional Health Director is better positioned to comment on the issue”.

Efforts by these reporters to talk to the Regional Health Director have since yielded no result”.

A visit to the office on January 14 and three phone calls subsequently to the secretary of the Regional Director were only met with “she is not around. She has not given me any date to call you”.

Medical negligence in Ghana
Allegations of professional negligence in Ghanaian hospitals are not new.

April 2010
A couple who lost their child through what they term “medical malpractice and professional negligence” demanded GHC 2 million compensation from the Lister Hospital and Fertility Center where the baby died.

Mr. Thomas Vaah and Elizabeth Vaah, who work with the United Nations and World Bank, respectively, plan to use the money as seed money for a foundation they have formed in memory of their late son to provide assistance for parents who undergo a similar ordeal.

The traumatised parents accused the hospital of “gross unprofessional conduct” which led to the death of Nyilale Vaah Junior, who was delivered on Tuesday March 9, 2012; almost 17 hours after Mrs. Vaah had been admitted and had received virtually no attention from healthcare professionals at the hospital.

The hospital’s management, however, denied the allegation.

May 2010
The husband of a 28-year-old woman, Dzifa Agboforti, alleged that unprofessional conduct of nurses of the Ketu South District Hospital at Aflao in the Volta Region resulted in the death of his wife and newborn baby.

Mr. Simon Ackumey said his wife reported to the health facility at about 8 a.m on April 8, 2010 to deliver but the nurses cared little about her presence.

Mr. Ackumey said the following day, the nurses asked his wife to move to another bed despite her plea that she was about to deliver.

He said when the wife got up and walked toward the bed, the baby dropped on the floor, compelling the nurses to rush to pick him and resuscitate him but he died two hours later.

November 2010
A young couple whose twin babies died during delivery at the Tema General Hospital on November 3, 2010 accused the Hospital of “murder” through negligence.

According to them, the two girls could have survived if nurses and doctors on duty had been more responsible and professional in attending to them.

March 2014
The family of 24-year-old pregnant lady at Laterbiokorhsie, a suburb of Accra accused authorities of the Korle-Bu Polyclinic of negligence, causing her death.

Abigail Boateng was almost three months pregnant when she died at the polyclinic on March 2, 2014.

NB: Story by Henking A. Adjase-Kodjo and Seth J. Bokpe

Henking is a journalist (an activist writer) and a blogger and can be reached via klonobi2007@gmail.com. You can follow him on twitter with the handle @henkingklonobi. Don't hesitate to leave the writer a comment on the story read.
The story as captured in the front page of The Mirror newspaper, Fri Jan 29- Feb 4, 2016

Front page of  The Mirror newspaper, Fri Jan 29- Feb 4, 2016

Page 3 of the newspaper